Case law - Wheels VAT case heard by ECJ

Thursday, September 20, 2012

The Wheels VAT case was heard in the early part of September by the European Court of Justice. 

The case had been launched by the NAPF and Wheels Common Investment Fund, a multi-employer scheme, in 2008, after a ruling in the ECJ that investment trusts were special investment funds and should be exempt from paying VAT on investment management services.  Wheels and NAPF had argued that defined benefit schemes should be exempt from paying VAT on investment management services. Defined contribution schemes are already exempt.  A VAT tribunal referred the case to the ECJ.

At the ECJ hearing, the European Commission agreed with HMRC and argued against granting an exemption to defined benefit schemes.  Employers and trustees of defined benefit schemes had been hopeful that if the ECJ ruled in favour of the NAPF and Wheels, defined benefit schemes would no longer have to pay VAT on investment management services and might even be entitled to a rebate for VAT already paid.  However the European Commission's view may now sway the odds in favour of HMRC.  The ruling is expected within the next six months. 

Thank you for all your assistance in helping to meet the deadline for the capital reduction exercise – your professionalism and friendly approach was appreciated.

Finance Director - Leading UK Company

Current News

Cohabitee wins right to pension

The Supreme Court has ruled that a nomination requirement relating to the payment of a survivor’s pension under a public sector pension scheme discriminated against cohabiting unmarried couples and should be disapplied.


Reversing Trustee Decisions

Trustees have on occasion relied on the “Hastings Bass” rule to unwind decisions that subsequently transpire to have unintended consequences. The scope to do so has been narrowed by the recent Supreme Court judgments in the jointly heard cases of Futter and another v HMRC and Pitt and another v HMRC.


EU Solvency Rules dropped

The European Commission has announced that it is dropping its plans for a new funding regime for pension schemes.


Pensions for Mortgages

Nick Clegg announces a new government idea to allow parents to use their pensions to help children onto the property ladder.